Free cash offer in minutes. No obligation to sell. Cars, trucks and SUVs, running or not
Compare

CarMax vs Carvana vs a local buyer.

Both big names will make you an instant offer. The trick is comparing them properly, and knowing when your car is better off with someone else.

By the Carquired teamPublished

Short answer

CarMax and Carvana both make instant online offers based on your answers about the car, then check the car before paying. CarMax usually finishes the sale at one of its stores, and Carvana usually picks the car up from you. Neither can tell you in advance which will pay more for your car, so get both offers on the same day with the same honest answers, then add a local buyer, especially if your car has problems.

How a CarMax offer works

You enter your plate or VIN and answer questions about the car’s condition, and CarMax gives you an offer online. To complete the sale you usually bring the car to a CarMax store, where they confirm it matches what you described before paying you. If your answers were accurate, the number should hold. If the car has issues you did not mention, expect it to change.

Comparing car offers on a laptop and phone at the kitchen counter

How a Carvana offer works

Carvana works the same way up front: plate or VIN, condition questions, instant offer. The difference is the handover. In most areas Carvana schedules a pickup at your home or another location, checks the car there, and pays you. Like CarMax, the offer depends on the car matching your answers.

Get your cash offer

Takes about two minutes. Costs nothing.

Your details go to Carquired only. We never sell or share them.

Side by side

CarMaxCarvanaLocal SoCal buyer
OfferInstant, onlineInstant, onlineOnline in minutes
Where you finishUsually at a storeUsually pickup or drop-offAt your home or work
Condition checkAt the storeAt pickupAt pickup
Cars with problemsPriced in, case by casePriced in, case by caseOften the reason people call
Who you deal withStore staffPickup teamOften the owner or a small team

Offers expire after a set number of days, so check the date on each one before you decide. Policies change too, so confirm the current details on each company’s own site.

Rows of used cars on a sunny dealership lot

Which one pays more?

Nobody can tell you that in advance, and anyone who claims one always pays more is guessing. Each buyer’s offer depends on what it needs in stock, where it can resell your car and how it prices the risks it sees. The only reliable test is to get the offers yourself.

  1. Get every offer on the same day, so the market has not moved between them.
  2. Give exactly the same answers each time, and be honest about warning lights, damage and accidents.
  3. Write down the number, the expiry date and any fees.
  4. Ask each one how they handle a loan payoff if you still owe money.
  5. Pick the best offer that you are confident will hold at pickup.
Buyer inspecting a crossover in the owner's driveway

When a local buyer makes more sense

The national buyers are at their best with clean, running, late-model cars. Cars with complications are where a local buyer is worth adding to the comparison: cars that do not run, salvage titles, failed smog, accident damage, a missing title or expired registration.

Carquired is a local Southern California buyer run by its owner, Hassan Ilyas. You get an offer online in about two minutes, we come to you, and we pay you on the spot. If you still owe money on the car, we pay the lender directly. Use our number as one of your comparisons. If CarMax or Carvana beat it, take their offer.

This guide is general information, not legal or financial advice.

Questions

Good questions, straight answers.

Not seeing yours? Start the form anyway. A real person reviews every offer and will answer anything when they reach out.

Is CarMax or Carvana better for selling my car?

It depends on the car and the day. Get both offers on the same day with the same answers and compare them, along with at least one local offer.

Do CarMax and Carvana buy cars that are financed?

Both say they can work with your lender to pay off a loan. Confirm the details for your lender when you get the offer.

Can I use one offer to negotiate with another?

You can show it, but instant-offer companies rarely negotiate. Treat each offer as final and simply take the best one.

Why would a local buyer pay more?

Not always. A local buyer can be a better fit for cars with problems, because they see the car in person and price it as it really is.

Find out what your car is worth today.

Two minutes, your plate number, and you will know. No fees, no pressure, no obligation.

Hassan IlyasOwner, Carquired
Get my cash offer